Posts Tagged ‘Homework’

A Life-Long Reader at Last?

Thursday, September 15th, 2011

Maybe it’s because she can read what she wants. Maybe it’s because she can read when she wants. Maybe it’s the Reading Log Workbook, cheering her on to read one million words this school year. Maybe it’s not having to do monthly book reports. Or maybe it’s just because she’s another year older, and has accepted the reading as part of her responsibilities. Whatever it is, I love not having to cajole, beg, plead or stand over her to get her to do her reading anymore.

My 6th grader’s new charter middle school doesn’t have a lot of requirements to go with their 30-minute daily reading assignment. In fact, she doesn’t even have to do it every night; it’s up to her to figure out how to read that amount each week. She’s opted to do it all on Sundays. Part of that is because of our hectic schedule lately, and finding a half-hour a night isn’t feasible many nights. But come Sunday, she reads. It only takes one reminder from me, and she gets out a timer, figures out how long to read before taking a break. She only asks that there be silence while she’s reading, a simple (and frankly, welcome by me) request. My older daughter either goes into her room, or puts on headphones. I get some housework done, and read during my breaks. After each reading session, we use the guide provided in her Reading Log Workbook to figure out how many words she’s read, she writes it down, I sign my initials. She takes her break, and then goes back to reading with no fuss when her break time is over.

This is simply not normal for us. Right or wrong, good or bad, every school year for the last 5 years, I’ve struggled to get her to like reading. It’s been frustrating on varying levels for me. I love to read, and I couldn’t understand why my daughter didn’t. I’ve role modeled a love of books her entire life! I’ve also felt like a failure as a parent because of it. Her summaries were sloppy, not focused on the main points. There were few books she loved. There were months where I helped her finish her monthly book reports far more than I felt comfortable doing, and there were months it didn’t get done. Her grades in that subject struggled, and I struggled with ideas for motivating her.

I think it’s a combination of all of the above, and a few others, that have made this year so different. Her English teacher this year is her favorite, so there’s more intrinsic motivation, and less willingness to tolerate disappointment from this teacher’s eyes. As I write this, she has laughed out loud plenty reading this installment of Harry Potter, one of her greatest current obsessions. This is her last installment of reading for this week, and not once has she checked the timer to see how much time she has left.

However long it took to get here, however many factors play into us being here now, I can only hope that struggles with reading are in the past.

April McCaffery is the single parent to two daughters, in 6th and 9th grade.

In Lieu of Homework

Friday, July 1st, 2011

One of the best things about summer, of course, is the absence of homework and monthly book reports. I used to get those “summer slide” workbooks, but by freeing ourselves of all of the recommendations, I’m finding the girls are actually learning this summer. All by themselves.

When my oldest daughter was making pancakes, she had to figure out how to measure cups and teaspoons without having those actual sizes available to her (for example, combining 1/4 and 1/2 cup of flour to get 3/4 cup). She is required to read 3 books over the summer break, but she is responsible for figuring out how much to read each day to accomplish the goal. She is also becoming more interested in current events now that I can watch the news every day because the girls aren’t buried in their homework.

My younger daughter has been reading for pleasure, finishing her Math workbook from 5th grade for her own amusement, and regularly writing in her journal.  She also makes up her own Math games. I implemented a new “earn an allowance” policy, and she figured out how much she could make for the summer if she did the highest amount possible, the minimum amount possible, and an average of the two.

I read recently in the New Yorker one writer’s belief that children’s imagination is to utilize language from which they don’t have personal experience. Summer allows them to create their own experiences when left to their own imagination.

Los Angeles Unified School District recently announced a new homework policy that limits homework effect on final grades to 10%. It recognizes that not all students have a quiet place and time every night to complete their homework. That’s not to say, that a student won’t be affected if they don’t complete their homework, but the policy forces homework to be balanced against other factors that should go in grading; quality of work, class participation, etc.

Homework is one of those areas where I think some teachers/schools rely too heavily on parental involvement. It assumes that someone is available to help from after-school to bedtime. It assumes that we have no other children that might also need our help. It assumes that we understand the assignment given and can offer a teacher’s skill level of assistance. It assumes that we understand the terminology the teacher used, even if the teaching methodologies have changed greatly since we were in school. It even assumes that the type of homework given will actually strengthen the learning process when helping me reduce a recipe might offer a greater comprehension of fractions.

During the summer is when I get to really assess what my children have actually learned. I can see it in the texts they send (I reply with any corrections in spelling), I can hear it in what they say and whether or not their vocabulary is accurate, and I even benefit from it when they help me google directions or other info.

Just like training can’t replace on the job experience, homework can’t replace the act of obtaining knowledge. It can help…but probably by only about 10%.

April McCaffery is the single mother to two daughters, going into 6th & 9th grade.

Reading For Book Reports vs Reading for Fun

Monday, April 11th, 2011

My 5th grade daughter’s monthly book reports have provided inspiration for many posts here: the offensive book report and teaching my daughter to skim are just the latest. At last, I can report on a month that wasn’t fraught with anxiety.

This month’s monthly topic of fantasy made it easy to help my daughter choose a book. She’s become a fan of Harry Potter. I bought her the entire set of books, and at last, she would have a chance to read one (with all the other monthly book reports, she hasn’t had time to read unassigned books).

Her teacher actually said no at first; the books were too long. The second book seemed doable, so I encouraged my daughter to read it anyway.

She took that book everywhere with her. She read in the car, she read before school, she read at night. She laughed out loud in some parts. She could shut out the world around her and get lost in the book. She sighed with content when she read the last page. She finished her reading a week ahead of time. And she’s even enjoying working on her circle report as a way to prolong the experience.

And this has been my point all along.

It’s not that the homework of reading every night is bad or wrong somehow, but that we can’t lose sight of the intent behind that assignment: to help our children become (more…)

Warning: This Book Report Might Be Offensive

Thursday, March 17th, 2011

The latest saga in my 5th grade daughter’s book report dramas. In order to make the reports “fun,” they are never assigned to do  just a written report. There’s the diorama book report, the book-in-a-bag book report, and this month, the cereal box book report. The assignment: make your book into a cereal, complete with name, “ingredients” of facts from the book, and games for the back of the box. Sounds simple enough.

Until, that is, you throw in the fact that the monthly genre is Biography, and the biography my daughter read was on Anne Frank. There is simply no way to accomplish this assignment without trivializing the Holocaust.

My daughter made her picture of Anne Frank for the front, made up a scramble word game on the back using the names of those  that lived in the Secret Annex, and we even came up with the “toy prize” to put in the cereal: a mini-diary. But what to name it?

My daughter picked “Concentration Cookies.” Terrible, right? Completely offensive. I tried to talk her out of it. Until I realized there was simply no way to name this cereal that wouldn’t trivialize the subject matter. (It had to be based on an already existing cereal, and couldn’t be the title of the book. For example, King-O’s for Martin Luther King, Jr.)

Not to mention, the report could easily have been done without reading the book. Skim a little, check out the Chronology, and have an older sister and mother who have read the Diary, seen the movie, seen the play, and you have everything you need to complete the assignment without actually having read the book.

My daughter read some parts, and skimmed others. I’m not really sure how much of the book my daughter absorbed, but since the assignment doesn’t call for any actual depth, it really didn’t matter. Which I find totally depressing.

I want my daughter to (more…)

Parenting the Procrastinator

Thursday, February 24th, 2011

My 5th grade daughter has long suffered from lack of motivation to do book reports.  I’ve used timers, I’ve taken away privileges, offered bribes, and sometimes just plain given up and let her suffer the consequences of lower grades. Given the current state of my relationship with her teacher (who still has not replied to my email), I’m also suffering from a lack of motivation.

She has three days left to complete a current report assignment, and was only on Chapter 3 as of this weekend. Sure, I gave the “coulda, woulda, shoulda” lecture, but that doesn’t help her now. So I’ve changed tactics again. When it’s too late to go back, all you can do is work with what you have. So I’m teaching my daughter the art of skimming. She’s now skimming the book, looking specifically for information that will help her with the book report.

Let’s face it, most of us have done it! Whether it’s Cliff’s Notes, only going back through the chapter to find the answers to the homework without reading the entire chapter, or picking a topic for a paper which you’ve used in a previous class, most of us have implemented short-cuts. Maybe there was a lot going on at home, maybe we didn’t like the teacher, maybe we were just plain lazy and had to get it done.

There’s a great line in Avenue Q’s “I Wish I Could Go Back to College” about this:

We could be…
Sitting in the computer lab,
4 A.M. before the final paper is due,
Cursing the world ’cause I didn’t start sooner,
And seeing the rest of the class there, too!

We all mess up. We all see how far we can push the boundaries. I’ve decided it’s best for my daughter to learn how to pull herself back up. Talk about preparing her for college!

————-

April McCaffery is the single mother to two daughters, in 5th and 8th grade.